top of page

Obedience vs. Behavior, Part 1: Talking to Dogs in a Language They Already Understand

Writer: Garret Eckhart
Garret Eckhart
Oct 29
18 min read

Our dogs are only with us for a small part of our lives, but to them, we are their whole life. I think about that a lot. It's a big part of why I do what I do, and it's why I believe we owe it to them to learn how to talk to them in their own language.

Obedience training is really human psychology applied to a dog. You take human words and link them to an action through conditioning. You say "sit," and the dog puts its butt on the ground. That's useful, and it's important. It just isn't the whole picture.

Behavior is dog psychology. Dogs don't rationalize. They don't sit there and think, "Oh, that's the pizza guy." They just react. And underneath all of it is the relationship between you and your dog. Without trust and respect, even the most obedient dog will blow you off the second something else looks more important.

That's why non-verbal communication works best with them, because dogs don't speak English. Words are just associations. You could teach a dog to sit on the word "pumpkin" if you conditioned it that way. The behavior side is dog psychology, and that's the language I want you to learn to speak.

A lot of people tell me they feel bad, or they don't want to be mean to their dog, or they don't want to hurt them. But that's how dogs communicate with each other. Think of a mama dog with a litter of puppies. She sets the rules, boundaries, and limitations for them. When she knows it's time to wean them off her milk and they still try to nurse, she'll show her teeth, she'll snarl, and she'll make physical contact with the puppy to tell them, hey, knock it off, we're not doing that anymore. That's the essence of my whole philosophy. I treat dogs as dogs, and I communicate with them in a way they innately and instinctually understand.

I've seen it over and over. A dog can do every command perfectly in the living room, but if he doesn't respect you as the leader, all that obedience goes out the window the moment he finds something more interesting than you. That's the difference between a dog that obeys and a dog that behaves.

Let me paint you a picture of what that looks like. My own dogs are really obedient. They'll do all the cool stuff and listen when I say something. But strip that away. When I get home from work, or when I let them out first thing in the morning, I don't say anything to them. I don't need to tell them to come, sit, stay, lay down. They just know, because of the structure and discipline I've instilled in them and the relationship underneath it. I might snap my fingers once or twice to get their attention, and as soon as I start walking in any direction, they simply follow. They won't stray, and they won't refuse to walk. Their focus is on me and my direction, on the walk and in life.

All my dogs are completely off-leash trained, and having a dog off leash goes deeper than obedience. Of course you can train it, and that works wonderfully 99 percent of the time. But you want your dog to choose you no matter what, over the other dog across the street or the squirrel running across the yard. My dogs follow me because they know I'm the leader. I'm the protector, the one who keeps them safe, the one who feeds them, and the one who takes them on walks and runs and adventures and gives them love and praise when it's appropriate.

Compare that to a lot of the dogs I meet. Some owners have to tell their dog to do something 24/7, because the second the dog isn't doing an obedience command, he's in the trash can or eating rabbit poop in the yard. When your dog is in a follower state of mind, you don't have to worry about him getting into trouble.

Obedience still matters a lot. Say your dog will barely sit five out of ten times, and only if you have food in your hand. Good traditional obedience is probably going to solve 85 to 90 percent of your behavior issues, because when you do it correctly, your dog naturally starts to see you as an authority figure with structure and discipline. Where people get stuck is the moment their dog chooses not to listen. There are trainers out there who are strictly positive reinforcement only, and a lot of owners come away believing that disciplining a dog or telling them no is frowned upon and should never happen. In reality, your dog craves structure and discipline. They have an innate need to be told yes, you can do that, and no, you can't. Setting the rules, boundaries, and limitations is even more important than the fancy tricks and advanced obedience. Without clear rules, your obedience just doesn't matter, because the second you're not there to tell them what to do, they'll find their way into trouble.

That's a big part of why I wanted to write this. Obedience training, behavior modification, and rehabilitation all get lumped together, and there's a lot of misinformation out there. A lot of companies stick to one method and one ideology. I want to break that mold, be a one-stop shop for dog owners, and do my part to blend it all together.

Everything I'm going to share with you here is about getting both, and it starts with you.

Energy and Leadership

Before we ever pick up a leash, I want to talk about you, because everything in this article comes back to energy. Who you are in the animal world is energy.

Every animal has its own way of communicating. Dogs have their language, and so do birds, and so do frogs. Out on the African safari, the lions communicate differently than the hippos do. But underneath all of it, who you are is energy. The lions don't mess with the hippos, and the cheetahs don't mess with the crocodiles. It goes far deeper than predator versus prey, because out there nearly everything is a predator in some form. Picture a lone cheetah walking along, minding his own business, when he comes across a big, full-grown male lion. That cheetah reads the confidence the lion is giving off and completely avoids him. And yet cheetahs have been known to come right up to people and interact with them in a totally safe, mild-tempered way. That all comes down to energy. Human beings are animals too, and the cheetah gravitates toward animals with equal or lesser energy than his own.

Dogs are very instinctual animals. You can take a three-to-four-month-old puppy, put him in the water, and he knows how to swim, because it's instinct. We humans have all our words and languages, and that takes away from the instinctual side of things. That's why I'm comfortable saying that dominance in the animal world is okay. It's how animals communicate and relate to one another. Some of what I'll describe later can look really nasty, even inhumane, to the average dog owner, and a lot of people run from it without ever getting educated on dominance and submission.

So again, who you are is energy. Dogs don't care if you're Black, White, Asian, blind, or missing a leg. They care about the energy you carry, and they read human energy better than we read ourselves. In a typical home, the dog often follows the most assertive person, frequently the father. A dog will naturally gravitate toward the softer energy of the kids or the mom, but views the father as the authority figure. That isn't about gender. It's about who carries that energy. This isn't every single house in America, but it's what you typically see. If your dog senses even a hint of weakness, frustration, or irritation, nothing works. Dogs innately don't follow weak energy. You have to stay calm, confident, and assertive. Calm is the number one ingredient in everything. When you have to correct your dog, you can't feel bad about it, you can't feel sorry for them, and you can't be sad about it.

It Starts With the Walk

Mastering the walk is where everything begins. Dogs move forward. That's what they do. Birds fly, fish swim, dogs walk. If you haven't mastered a simple walk, nothing else really matters.

That's why day one with every client starts right here, with mastering the walk. Some dogs pick it up quickly. Others are freight trains that need twenty minutes of calm patience. I hand owners an empty leash and tell them to walk like they're carrying a purse, a briefcase, or a work bag into the mall, with their head up, shoulders square, and a destination in mind. The two most common mistakes I see are a double-handed death grip or a leash wrapped around the hand, which creates constant tension, and staring down at the dog instead of looking ahead. A true leader grabs the leash and just goes, and the dog reads that energy and follows.

Here's what I see most of the time. A dog on a flexi leash, strapped into a harness, ten or fifteen feet away from their owner. They're completely disconnected. They don't care who's on the other end of the leash because they're off in their own world, sniffing around and eating rabbit poop. Harnesses were invented so dogs could pull things safely. They weren't invented to stop pulling or to build a connection. Think about strapping a harness onto the back of a horse and trying to drag him around. A horse is many times larger and stronger than a person, so it would be impossible. That's why horses wear a head halter and you direct them by moving the head. On a harness, the opposition reflex kicks in. The dog feels that pressure and pulls even harder. That's instinct, and you'll find it in every animal. Our job is to teach them to ignore that instinct and yield instead.

The first thing I do is change the equipment. I start with a simple four-to-five-foot slip leash. Fit nice and snug all the way at the top of the neck, just behind the ears, it gives you what I call power steering. That shorter leash forces proximity, and it starts to reprogram the dog. Don't be surprised if your dog still seems disconnected at first, even after the switch. That's normal. The equipment change is only the first step toward building something deeper.

Next, we teach the dog to yield to leash pressure instead of fighting it. If you give them pressure upward, they put their butt on the ground. Pressure to the right, they move to the right. Pressure to the left, they move to the left. Put the leash on, stay calm and confident, and give a little pressure in one direction. Nine times out of ten, they'll be severely disconnected from you at first, and that's okay. The second they look at you or move toward the pressure, mark it with "yes" and reward. For most dogs that "yes" alone is enough, but you can put the cherry on top and pay them with a piece of food, some praise, or a toy. That's positive reinforcement. You're adding something of value so they want to repeat the behavior. Be patient with them. If they freeze or lean into it, just wait. Don't yank. Once they're yielding consistently and you know they understand what the pressure means, you can correct them when they choose to ignore it. For me, that's usually when they're yielding about seven out of ten times. A precise correction starts with slack in the leash. If the line is already tight, a pop turns into a pull and does nothing. So you create slack, give a swift pop to break their concentration and bring their attention back to you, and then you mark and reward.

The easiest way I've found to teach this is with a spare leash. I hold one end, the owner holds the other, and at first I tell them to keep it as tight as possible and try to stop me. When the line is already tight and I pull, they just hold on harder, because the tension was there to begin with. But when I create slack and then give the pop, they can't resist it. Once they feel that in their own hand, it really clicks what they should be doing when the leash is attached to their dog. Then I stand back, observe, and coach them while they handle their own dog. Handling skills go a long way with everything.

The milestone is a loose leash, usually on the left side, with the dog never passing your heels. The left side is just what I do personally. The right side works too. I keep the leash in my left hand only. Most people call this a heel, and that's the obedience side of it. They can be next to you or behind you, just not out in front. Done right, over time this puts your dog into a follower state of mind. Dogs are pack animals. They can be at the front, middle, or back of the pack. Some are natural leaders and some are natural followers. The trouble starts when a natural follower doesn't get structure from their owner. They feel like somebody has to lead, so they take the job themselves. Your dog doesn't feel like you're able to lead them and keep them safe. That's where you get reactivity and disconnection on the leash.

Tools Are Just Ways to Communicate

That brings me to equipment in general. Every tool you put on a dog is there for communication. Think about the people in your life. Some prefer a text, some want a phone call, some would rather talk face to face, and some still like email. You match the channel to what that particular dog actually hears. This part is for dog owners, not just trainers. A trainer just speeds up the process of figuring out which channel your dog hears best.

Level one is a simple slip leash or a martingale collar. Both have action, unlike a flat collar, which just presses on one spot and can risk tracheal injury in dogs that pull. A slip leash has a little more action than a martingale, meaning it can apply pressure easily instead of one stagnant pressure in one spot. Level two is a plastic pinch collar. It gives you better pressure distribution and precision, so you can correct your dog easily and fairly. Level three is a Herm Sprenger prong collar, and that's the top tier when it comes to training collars that make a real impact with your dog. It's impossible for a dog to choke themselves out or break skin on a properly fitted Herm Sprenger. Choking can happen a lot on a standard flat collar, and it can happen on a martingale or a slip leash too. That's the only brand I trust, because they're the original German maker. I work in levels for a reason. If I start on a slip leash and it just isn't effective for that dog, I move up to the plastic pinch, and onward from there. You only go up a level when the one you're on stops working.

Contrary to popular belief, the prongs on a prong collar aren't sharp like razor blades. I show owners this by putting one on my own arm or neck and letting them pull me around, and then I let them feel it for themselves. It doesn't cut me, and a dog's skin is thicker and a bit stronger than ours. Dogs have fur, too. On big, strong, powerful double-coated breeds, a martingale or a slip leash just isn't going to have any effect, and a prong is actually the most effective tool. Most people are genuinely surprised. This powerful tool just isn't what the media has led them to believe.

The prong is a training tool, not something your dog wears 24/7. Your flat collar is for tags and everyday wear. A lot of people assume that if their dog needs a prong collar, they'll need it for the rest of the dog's life. That isn't the case. You'll know you're ready to hang up the prong and step back down to a slip leash or flat collar when you no longer have to correct your dog for misbehaving or for not listening when you ask them to do something. At that point the dog already knows the rules, boundaries, and limitations. Keep in mind that tension on the leash is a signal all by itself. It tells the dog something is wrong even when nothing is. A loose leash tells them they're doing everything right.

A head halter is rare for me. I mainly use one on tall, powerful breeds like a Great Dane. Dogs learn nose first, then eyes, then ears. That's the order those senses open up at birth. If you control the nose, you control the dog. You control where the head goes, you control the body. It's also why the slip leash or prong collar sits snugly right behind the ears.

Corrections, Calm Surrender, and What I Consider the Maximum Consequence

Tools only matter if you know how to use them fairly, so let's talk about corrections. My definition of discipline is to teach, so a fair correction is just another part of teaching. Positive reinforcement shapes about 85 to 90 percent of training. It's how we mold and shape new behaviors. But when a dog knows the behavior and chooses to blow you off, you need accountability. "You need to come" instead of "Please come back." That's what builds respect. Fair corrections are precise and well-timed, and they're matched to the energy and size of the dog in front of you. Just like people, dogs learn in different ways. If a dog is very intense, high-strung, and all over the place, the correction may need to be a bit stronger. A more mellow dog who just needs to learn that commands are required rather than optional would take a more mellow correction. A correction that feels harsh to one dog would feel like nothing more than a fly landing on another. It's not one size fits all, but the underlying communication is the same. A correction for a five-pound Maltese would be far less powerful physically than one for a 150-pound Mastiff, but the psychological effect is the same. With any dog, you want precision over power. A heavy-handed yank-and-crank is far too harsh and completely out of line.

If you find yourself correcting the same thing more than five or six times, something is wrong with the method, not the dog. Twenty times is way too much. Either you're not giving a firm and precise enough correction, or you're not following through enough to get your dog to really surrender to the situation. Patience is key. If you don't have patience, you don't have anything. Some dogs get it in one rep. Others are pushier and take longer, especially the front-of-the-pack types. Breed, age, temperament, and natural disposition all play into it, but it isn't really a breed thing. It comes down to the energy of your dog.

Consequences come in levels, so let me walk you through how they build. Say you have an aggressive dog, one who's been in fights and has drawn blood from another dog. I start with the walk, and I have the owner master the walk too, in a controlled environment with no other dogs around. That builds the relationship and starts switching the leadership roles, so the dog sees that the owner is the one in charge. Then we bring in another dog, preferably one he's fought before, so his last memory of that dog was a fight. If he starts to build, showing teeth or starting to growl, I give a mild consequence. Maybe a leash pop, a snap of my fingers, or a sharp sound like hey or no, or even just shh. Anything to break that focus and that state of mind. But if he actually commits to an attack, that deserves the maximum consequence.

Physically putting a dog on their side in a submissive position is my personal maximum consequence, for any dog in any situation. It can apply to severe reactivity where a standard correction doesn't get through, to a truly aggressive dog who carries out a full-blown attack on a dog or a person, or to a dog that goes for the trash can a third time after two firm corrections. I do not condone hanging a dog by the neck, whipping, kicking, or hitting. None of that is ever acceptable. Screaming and yelling and smacking a dog in the face are on that list too. When I put a reactive or aggressive dog on their side, it may look terrible. The dog may be growling and snarling and snapping. But I'm not hurting the dog in any way. I'm communicating with him in his own native language.

Here's why I do it this way. Picture a pack of five dogs with a strict, clearly defined leader. Two of the followers decide to get into a fight, and one of them instigates it. The leader steps in, corrects the dog that started it, goes over the top of him, and pins him to the ground, all while staying calm and confident. No frustration, no irritation, no anger. Once it's calmed down, he just gets up and walks away as if nothing happened. Something happened, he took care of it, and now it's over. Everybody moves on. Your dog is not a human, and you're not going to hurt their feelings, because dogs are present. They live in the moment. Anything I do, dogs would do amongst each other.

Dogs have a natural order of fight, flight, avoidance, and submission. The leash takes flight off the table, so the options left are fight, avoid, or calm submission. You stay calm, confident, and assertive, and you ride the wave until the dog gives it up and surrenders. If you back off while they're still fighting or avoiding, the dog won, and he just learned that the behavior you were trying to correct is acceptable. Aggressive dogs are often easier to rehabilitate than fearful ones, because they give it up the instant you stick with it correctly.

It's easy to confuse a dog in a calm surrender state of mind with a dog that has shut down. A dog shuts down when someone tries to discipline or correct them without being calm, confident, and assertive. You can be as confident and assertive as you want, but if you're frustrated, irritated, or angry, it's all for nothing. That's when a dog shows the shutdown that people interpret as breaking the spirit or changing the personality. Calmness is the most important part. When it's done correctly and with the right energy, correcting a dog and physically putting them into a submissive position should leave you with a dog in a calm, submissive state of mind, and when it's over, everything goes right back to normal. Never attempt this without a professional. A lot of people can get hurt doing it incorrectly or without the right state of mind. If you're an owner, do it only under the supervision of a professional.

This isn't only for the crisis moments, either. My own dogs will drop into that submissive position on a finger snap and two or three steps toward them, even if they're just a little too excited in the morning. Maybe they're playing with each other, or I've just let them out of their crates to go potty. Affection only happens in that calm surrender state. If you pet or praise an excited or anxious dog, you reinforce that state. It works for everyday handling, too. If I want to take them out for an activity or clip their nails, they surrender to whatever I'm leading them through. Think about trying to get a dog into the bathtub. He may not fight you, but he'll go into flight. He puts on the brakes and tries to run from it or avoid it. What you want is for him to surrender to the situation, and that applies to anything you want him to do. Love is unconditional, and a dog will always love you. Trust and respect are earned through structure and discipline.

A Real Story: Bear, the Reactive Border Collie

I want to share one client story, because it shows how the right tool and the right timing come together. I worked with a younger woman and her two-year-old male Border Collie. He was getting more and more reactive on leash, barking and lunging at other dogs. She had him on a regular leash clipped to a harness, and it's quite literally impossible to correct effectively on a harness. A harness has no action. It just makes it easier for them to pull. We switched him to a slip leash, and that alone improved her handling by about seventy-five percent.

This was reactivity, not aggression. Before we started, she told me about a time he reacted to another dog roughly a hundred to a hundred fifty feet away. He pulled so hard she lost the leash, and he sprinted over. When he got there, he just sniffed and sized the other dog up. No fight. A truly aggressive dog would have attacked.

When his reactivity kicked in, the slip leash didn't have enough action, so we moved to a Herm Sprenger prong. We put him in a situation where he was likely to react, and as soon as he started to build, I gave one solid, perfectly timed correction. That one correction was really all he needed to understand that he wasn't supposed to act that way. It was night and day. His whole world changed in that one moment. From then on, whenever I held the leash, he was perfect. It took her two or three repetitions, because her timing was a little late at first. The key is the timing of it all. Once she landed a clean one, the message carried over to her too. He understood he had to behave with both of us.

The Trash Can

Not every correction happens out on a walk. Here's what it looks like in everyday life at home. You're sitting on the couch and your dog heads for the trash can. A lot of people would reach for a "leave it" or a recall. That can stop the moment, but it doesn't teach the dog to ignore the trash can. It's a band-aid, management through obedience, and the underlying behavior is still there. So the next day your dog goes for the trash can again, you say "leave it" or call him over again, and you're stuck repeating that over and over.

Don't get me wrong. "Leave it" is a great command, and recall is a very important skill to have. "Leave it" is far more broad and can apply to many different things, like when you're out on a walk and your dog is about to get into some rabbit poop. It just isn't built to teach your dog that the trash can itself is off limits.

What I do is catch them by surprise if I can, give a physical correction with no verbal command, and then stay right there next to the trash can until they drop into a calm, submissive state. To catch them by surprise, I'll wait until they're so invested in the trash can that they don't hear me get up. I don't say "leave it" or any other command. The correction snaps their brain out of whatever they're doing. That creates a new memory and a clear rule that the trash can is off limits. You can do the same thing for shoes, the remote, the counter, anything. Over time it all stacks up into a full household rulebook. Curious, excitable dogs take longer than mellow ones, but the approach stays the same.

There's one tool I haven't gotten into yet, and that's the e-collar. It's the last tool in my progression, so it gets its own article in Part 2, along with recall and going off leash. Before we get there, I want to bring it all home.

A Leader Worth Following

All of it brings me back to where we started. The biggest mistake I see owners make is giving lots of love without enough structure and discipline. Love is unconditional. Trust and respect are earned. Just because your dog loves you doesn't mean they trust you or respect you. Say another dog runs up on you and gets into a fight with your dog. If you don't handle that properly in that moment, your relationship is going to be tarnished, and your dog won't trust that you're able to lead them and protect them from anything. Anything you want to do with your dog is possible through proper obedience, relationship building, leadership, structure, and clear rules. The walk, the tools, the e-collar, and the ability to put your dog on their side in a submissive position all serve the same purpose. They give your dog a language they already understand and a leader worth following.

Recent Posts

See All
Kids and Dogs — Rules for Both Sides of the Leash

The rule I give kids around dogs is no touch, no talk, no eye contact. Ignore the dog completely. That should be a rule for all kids under the age of 10, and all interactions between children and dogs

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page