Obedience vs. Behavior, Part 2: The E-Collar, Recall, and Speaking Their Language Off Leash
In Part 1, I talked about the heart of how I train. Obedience is the human side, behavior is the dog side, and everything I do comes down to talking to your dog in a language they already understand, with you as a calm leader worth following. Every tool you put on a dog is part of that conversation, and the e-collar is the one people misunderstand the most.
The E-Collar
Once the leash work and the house rules are in place, there's one more tool in the progression. The e-collar is always the last tool, never the first. I only introduce it after the dog has mastered obedience on a four-to-five-foot leash, and then on longer lines up to thirty feet.
Long lines have their time and place, especially when you're teaching recall at a distance. Always start small. Start on your normal four-to-five-foot leash, then move to a ten-to-fifteen-foot line, then twenty or twenty-five, then thirty. The recall works the same way at every length. Send your dog out, wait until they're distracted, and give the recall command. Some people say "come." I say the dog's name and then "here." If they don't respond, a quick pop on the long line grabs their attention and corrects them for not listening. Nine times out of ten, that redirects them right back to me. For the first couple of reps, I mark and reward. Beyond that, if they hear the recall and choose to ignore you, bam, correction, and they come back to you.
My top brand is Dogtra, specifically the 280C (now the 280X). E-Collar Technologies' EZ900 is a strong second. Those cheap forty-to-sixty-dollar Amazon collars are useless. They have no fine levels, so it's basically pain or more pain. Dogtra gives you levels from 1 to 127 in some cases, sometimes even higher, and that fine control is what makes or breaks it. E-Collar Technologies runs from 0 to 100. You really do get what you pay for, and the more you spend, the more features you get. Some collars have GPS or LED lights built in. If you asked me which one to buy, I'd tell you to go to Dogtra's website or Tom Davis's website and get the Tom Davis Edition 280C 2.0. It has nick, continuous, and continuous nick stimulation levels from 0 to 127. It has a boost feature, which allows you to set a specific level adjustment at the press of a button rather than having to manually turn the dial. It has a lock feature to lock in a specific level so you don't have to worry about the level changing by accident. It has the HPP, which stands for high performance pager and is just an intense vibration. And the 2.0 version adds the tone, which I love for teaching a recall.
Finding the right level starts low. Begin at level two with a nick, which is one quick stimulation rather than continuous, and watch for an ear flick, a glance, a head tilt, or any change in behavior. If you see nothing that tells you your dog can feel it, go up incrementally one or two levels at a time. Once you know your dog feels it, drop back one or two levels so they barely feel it. That number is your working level. Every dog's working level is different. It could be a three or a four, a six or a seven, or a twelve, fourteen, even sixteen. The size of the dog and the length of their hair both play into it. You could have identical littermates, the exact same size, and one lands at four while the other lands at fourteen. It all comes down to the individual dog. Say the first sign they feel it is at twelve. Back down to ten or eleven, and that's their working level. I explain this because I don't want anyone trying a two, seeing nothing, and thinking it doesn't work. At this stage it's very low-level stimulation, because you're pairing it with your verbal cues so your dog understands that when they feel that sensation, it means you're talking to them. That's how I introduce a remote collar to any dog on the planet, not just for recall.
Both contact points have to touch skin. On double coats or long-haired dogs, part the fur. If one point is sitting on fur, the dog feels nothing or gets a distorted signal, and the working level reads artificially high. Fix the contact and restart from zero. The collar itself should be snug enough that it doesn't slide around on its own, but not so tight that it chokes. Owners who loosen it because it feels tight to them are unknowingly raising the number they think their dog needs.
Recall and Going Off Leash
Depending on the model, your collar might have nick, continuous, and vibrate, or it might have nick, continuous, continuous nick, vibrate, and a sound. If it doesn't have a sound, I use the standard stimulation for recall.
For recall, I say the dog's name, give the command ("here" is what I use), and hold continuous stimulation until they commit or arrive. If your collar has a tone, tone recall is the gold standard for off-leash work. Hold the tone from the moment you say the command until your dog gets to you, and after a few reps the sound itself means come. Keep the verbal cue as a backup in case of a dead battery. The long line doesn't come off until your dog recalls perfectly on tone alone, with no verbal and no leash pressure, under any circumstance, while still on that thirty-foot line. You also master the walk on a slack thirty-foot line, because the dog knows what's attached and will take advantage of it if they want to. When your dog makes the decision on their own to stay next to you, that's when you know you can go fully off leash.
When you do take the long line off, start in a low-distraction environment, like a park early in the morning or in the evening when not a lot is going on. Then build from there into busier and busier places, until your dog chooses to listen without you repeating commands or giving corrections. If you only ever practice your off-leash recall in the backyard, that's the only place you've done it. You can't expect your dog to put it together at a crowded park with other dogs and animals and kids and people running all over the place. That's like going from kindergarten to 12th grade without doing first through 11th. If you move up and your dog keeps failing, that's your sign to step back down to a lower-distraction environment and keep working on it. Build it up the right way, through every situation you can think of, and the places you can take your dog and trust them to behave are really limitless.
The Misconceptions
I hear the same worries about e-collars all the time, so let's clear a few up. A lot of people think e-collars are tasers or electric shocks. They aren't. It's stimulation similar to the TENS unit a physical therapist uses. A chiropractor might use one on your back, too. It's basically a muscle stimulator. Where a lot of people get the wrong idea is from the nasty content out there of someone putting an e-collar on a dog, turning it all the way up with no introduction at all, and expecting the dog to listen. That's completely absurd, and I don't condone anybody who does it. Any tool used improperly can do harm. A ballpoint pen can be used to write a beautiful poem or, when used improperly, to stab someone. Used for its intended purpose, it's a wonderful piece of technology.
The idea that e-collars burn holes in the neck usually comes from leaving the collar on 24/7 in the same spot. It's like wearing a watch for days without ever taking it off. The skin gets irritated. It can get raw and even infected, because bacteria build up under there. Most people take their watch off at night for exactly that reason. It's the same concept for e-collars and prong collars. Leave either one on snug 24/7 and of course the skin is going to get irritated and develop sores. Rotate the collar every hour on long days. Say you're out training or at the beach all day. Every hour, move it to a different position on the neck so it isn't sitting in the same spot forever. Stock contact points are stainless steel, which is a chromium-nickel alloy, and the nickel can trigger reactions in sensitive dogs. There's a middle tier of hypoallergenic stainless with a higher chromium-to-nickel ratio. Titanium is completely nickel-free, biocompatible, and conducts stimulation better. So if your dog develops a hot spot even though you're rotating the collar every hour like you should, the metal itself may be the problem. Titanium points are an added expense, so I'd wait until you actually see a hot spot before buying them. If a hot spot does show up, take a break, disinfect it, let it heal completely, then switch to titanium points and reintroduce the collar.
Freedom Built on Trust
The e-collar doesn't replace anything I talked about in Part 1. It's built on top of it. The walk, the leash work, the house rules, and calm leadership all come first, and the collar is just one more way to talk to your dog once they already understand you. Used the right way, it's a wonderful communication tool that can give your dog a fulfilling life of freedom, and give you a dog who makes the decision on their own to stay next to you.

Comments