top of page

The Harness Debate — Why Most Harnesses Make Pulling Worse

Writer: Garret Eckhart
Garret Eckhart
Nov 4
1 min read

When an owner tells me their dog pulls and they're using a harness, the first thing I ask is if they know what the harness was invented for. It was invented for dogs to pull things safely. Not to stop dogs from pulling.

The Opposition Reflex

What happens when you put a pulling dog in a harness is it becomes easier and safer for them to pull. That's the opposition reflex. It's an instinctual behavior where an animal automatically pushes or pulls against applied physical pressure or restraint, rather than moving away from it. Your dog starts to pull, then they feel all that pressure pulling against them, so they pull even harder.

What I Use Instead

I typically start with a simple slip leash, then move to a plastic pinch collar, and then a Herm Sprenger prong collar. But it all depends on the dog. A properly fitted prong gives you the power steering you need in order to guide your dog on walks and correct them when needed. It is a training collar and not something to be left on 24/7.

When a Harness Makes Sense

The only time I would recommend a harness is if you're doing work where you want your dog to pull and to pull safely. Like certain pulling sports. Harnesses do not stop pulling. Anything you see online labeled as a no-pull harness is a scam and a lie. Harnesses let your dog pull safely and make them pull harder.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page